
Best For
Teams this article is built to help
Category: Teacher Resources
Evidence
What backs this guide
Curated references are cited at the end of the article.
Materials
What you can leave with
- Condensed key takeaways
- 2 bonus downloads
- Interactive self-check quiz
If you are a first-year teacher, late October may be the week the energy of August runs out. Conferences are on the calendar, your first formal observation is coming, and one or two students are on your mind every night. This is not the month to build a bigger data system. It is the month to shrink it: one student, one behavior, a two-minute log at the end of the day, and a weekly look at your own graph. Small habits survive a hard month. Ambitious ones are the first thing to go.
What the Phases of First-Year Teaching Actually Say
Many induction programs share a short article by Ellen Moir, "Phases of First-Year Teaching." Moir wrote it in 1990 for the California New Teacher Project newsletter, drawing on the Santa Cruz New Teacher Project's work with new teachers, and the New Teacher Center still publishes it (Moir, 2011); the version it publishes describes that work as reaching nearly 1,500 new teachers. The phases come from new teachers' journal entries and end-of-year program evaluations. They describe a common pattern, not the findings of a controlled study, and Moir says plainly that not every new teacher goes through this exact sequence.
The Five Phases, as Moir Dates Them
Anticipation
Begins during student teaching and carries new teachers through the first few weeks of school.
Survival
The first month, when everything is new and there is little time to reflect.
Disillusionment
Begins after six to eight weeks of nonstop work. Its intensity and length vary from teacher to teacher.
Rejuvenation
Generally begins in January, helped along by winter break, and lasts into spring with ups and downs.
Reflection
Begins in May, as teachers look back and picture their second year, which starts a new round of anticipation.
Moir's text does not name a month for disillusionment. The New Teacher Center's more recent guidance describes it as usually lasting from November through January (New Teacher Center, n.d.). But do the arithmetic for your own calendar: if school started in late August or early September, six to eight weeks lands in October. That is why "the October slump" is a fair description for many new teachers, even though the timing shifts with your start date.
Two details in Moir's description matter for this article. First, she names back-to-school night, parent conferences, and the first formal evaluation as new stressors that arrive in this phase. If conferences are coming up, our 15-minute plan for bringing behavior data to conferences will help. Second, she notes that classroom management is a major source of distress during disillusionment. In other words, behavior is often what new teachers are worrying about when the slump hits.
Why Behavior Data Is the First Habit to Slip
In September, many new teachers start a clipboard, a spreadsheet, or a set of tally sheets. By late October, the clipboard is under a stack of papers. That is not a character flaw. When every hour is spoken for, anything that does not have to happen today stops happening.
The cost is real, though. Without a record, memory fills the gap, and memory on a hard week keeps the worst moments. "Nothing is working" is a very easy conclusion to reach at 9 p.m. on a Thursday. A few weeks of simple counts often tell a more accurate story: the behavior happens mostly in one routine, the calm days outnumber the hard ones, or a strategy you started is helping a little. You are already noticing these patterns. Writing them down is what keeps them from being swallowed by a bad day.
The opposite trap is just as common: trying to track everything, then reviewing none of it. More data is not better data when nobody has time to look at it.
Six Small Habits That Survive a Hard Month
Consider a hypothetical first-year fourth-grade teacher we'll call Ms. Park. One student, whom we'll call Owen, calls out during whole-group math several times a lesson, and the class follows his lead. Here is what a sustainable October system could look like for her.
1. One student, one behavior
Pick the student you think about most, or the one you are most likely to be asked about at conferences or a student support meeting. Then pick one behavior and define it in a sentence another adult could use: "Calling out: saying an answer or comment aloud during whole-group math without being called on." Everything else waits.
This is about the tracking you choose to add. Data collection written into a student's IEP or behavior plan continues as written; if that load feels unmanageable, bring it to your case manager or mentor rather than letting it drop.
2. A two-minute end-of-day log
During the routine, keep a tally on a sticky note or a clicker. Before you leave the room, take two minutes: write the total, the date, and one line of context ("sub in the afternoon," "assembly," "new seating chart"). Same time every day, so it becomes automatic. A frequency tracking template is enough. Calm days get logged too; a zero is a data point.
3. Read your own graph once a week
On Friday, look at the week as a picture, not a memory. Is the level higher, lower, or about the same as last week? Did the hard days line up with something, such as a schedule change or an event? (The October 30 party and other event days are worth tagging for exactly this reason.) Write one sentence about what you see and, at most, one thing you will try next week. If you log in Classroom Pulse, your entries become a graph you can open on Friday, and a phase line marks the week you started something new, so you can see before and after on the same page.
4. Count your own behavior-specific praise
This is the habit with the strongest research behind it. The federal practice guide on teacher-delivered behavioral interventions rates acknowledging expected behavior through attention, praise, and rewards as a strong-evidence recommendation (Lane et al., 2024). The hard part is remembering to do it when you are stressed. In a study with five middle school teachers, self-monitoring helped: recording each specific praise statement, by tallying or using a counter, worked better than the other self-monitoring methods tested, and the teachers preferred the counter (Simonsen et al., 2013).
For Ms. Park, that means a second tally during the same math block: each time she names what a student did well ("Owen, you raised your hand and waited. That's how we share in math."), she clicks once. She is not aiming for a magic ratio. She is watching her own number rise over a few weeks. Our guide to behavior-specific praise and common mistakes has more examples.
5. Ask a mentor to co-observe for fifteen minutes
Invite your mentor or a trusted colleague to sit in during the routine and count the same behavior with your definition. Afterward, compare totals. Close totals are a good first sign, but two people can reach the same total by counting different moments, so also compare counts for each five-minute block. If they are far apart, the definition needs tightening, which is a useful thing to learn now. The free IOA calculator will compute the agreement for you. Ask the observer one more question: "What did you see happen right before he called out?" An extra pair of eyes catches antecedents you miss while you are teaching.
6. Change one thing at a time
When the graph is flat, it is tempting to try five new strategies on Monday. Pick one, give it at least a week or two, and keep logging. If you change everything at once, the data cannot tell you what helped. Our quick-win strategies for new teachers is a good place to choose that one thing.
What to Stop Doing This Month
Stop
- Tracking every student or every behavior
- Rebuilding the week from memory on Friday afternoon
- Writing labels such as "defiant" or "disrespectful"
- Switching strategies every day
- Doing data work at home late at night
- Treating the graph as a grade on your teaching
Start or Keep
- One student and one defined behavior
- A tally during the routine and a total before you leave
- Describing what you saw: "called out an answer four times"
- One change, given a week or two
- A logging window inside the school day
- Reading the graph as information about a routine
The last item deserves emphasis. A rising line in October is information about a student and a routine. It is not a verdict on whether you belong in this profession. Moir describes new teachers in this phase questioning both their commitment and their competence. Data that is small, honest, and read weekly is one of the few things that can push back on that feeling with facts.
For Mentors and Principals
Support matters during this phase. A review of 15 empirical studies of induction programs for beginning teachers found that most supported positive effects on teacher commitment and retention, classroom practices (including classroom management), and student achievement. There were exceptions, including a large randomized trial that found no effect on retention or classroom practices (Ingersoll & Strong, 2011). Here is what support can look like around behavior data in October and November.
- 1Name the phase. The New Teacher Center recommends discussing the common pattern of the first year openly so new teachers know others feel the same way (New Teacher Center, n.d.).
- 2Keep support visits separate from evaluation. The first formal evaluation is already a stressor. A co-observation where you count a behavior together should feel like help, not a second evaluation.
- 3Ask about the graph, not the class. "What does your data show for Owen this week?" leads somewhere. "How's your class?" usually leads to the worst moment of the week.
- 4Help them drop something. Help a new teacher decide what can wait. Do not add new data requirements in October unless they are truly needed.
- 5Help with the hard student, concretely. If a student's behavior is persistent or unsafe, connect the teacher with the behavior specialist or student support team and help them assemble what they already have. Our guide to a four-week data packet before an FBA referral shows what that can include.
More classroom data workflows for new and experienced teachers are on our page for teachers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does every first-year teacher go through a slump?
No. Moir says directly that not every new teacher goes through this exact sequence, and the intensity and length of the hard phase vary. The phases are a useful map, not a prediction about you.
Is a two-minute log really enough?
For one defined behavior in one routine, a tally during the routine and a two-minute total at the end of the day is enough to see a trend and talk about it with a mentor or family. If the team later needs a functional behavior assessment, the specialist will add more detailed observations. Your consistent counts give that work a starting point.
What if my graph gets worse after I start a strategy?
Check the context first: an event, a substitute, or a schedule change can explain a hard week. Then check whether the strategy happened as planned. If the line stays up for a couple of weeks with the strategy in place, bring the graph to your mentor and decide together what to adjust.
Should I track the student's behavior or my own?
Both, if you can keep it small. One student behavior and one teacher behavior (your praise statements) in the same routine gives you the most useful picture: you can see whether a change in what you do lines up with a change in what the student does.
Small Enough to Keep
The goal for October is not a perfect data system. It is a habit small enough to survive the hardest stretch of your first year: one student, one behavior, a tally, a two-minute total, and a Friday look at the graph. If Moir's map holds for you, rejuvenation tends to arrive in January. When it does, you will walk into it with two or three months of honest data instead of a stack of half-finished forms.
Pick your student and your behavior today, and set up the sheet before you go home.
References
Ingersoll, R. M., & Strong, M. (2011). The impact of induction and mentoring programs for beginning teachers: A critical review of the research. Review of Educational Research, 81(2), 201-233. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654311403323
Lane, K. L., Baldy, T., Becker, T., Bradshaw, C., Dolan, V., Dymnicki, A., Freeman, B., Holian, L., Lemire, S., McIntosh, K., Moulton, S., Nese, R., Payno-Simmons, R., Porowski, A., & Sutherland, K. (2024). Teacher-delivered behavioral interventions in grades K-5 (WWC 2025001). National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. https://ies.ed.gov/ncee/WWC/PracticeGuide/31
Moir, E. (2011, August 17). Phases of first-year teaching. New Teacher Center. https://newteachercenter.org/resources/phases-of-first-year-teaching/ (Original work published 1990 in the California New Teacher Project newsletter, California Department of Education)
New Teacher Center. (n.d.). The November-January slump: Supporting new teachers through the disillusionment phase. https://newteachercenter.org/resources/the-november-january-slump-supporting-new-teachers-through-the-disillusionment-phase/
Simonsen, B., MacSuga, A. S., Fallon, L. M., & Sugai, G. (2013). The effects of self-monitoring on teachers' use of specific praise. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 15(1), 5-15. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098300712440453
Put This Into Practice
Turn the article into action with ready-to-use materials. Downloads stay open; emailed resources and quiz results are opt-in.
Key Takeaways
- Ellen Moir's phases of first-year teaching place disillusionment after six to eight weeks of school, which falls in October for many teachers who started in late August or early September, though not every teacher follows the sequence
- Shrink your data system: one student, one defined behavior, a tally during the routine, and a two-minute total before you leave
- Read your own graph every Friday and change only one thing at a time so the data can show what helped
- Count your own behavior-specific praise with a tally or counter, and ask a mentor to co-observe and count the same behavior
- Mentors and principals help most by naming the phase, keeping support visits separate from evaluation, and asking about the graph instead of the class
Bonus Materials
Clean downloads to pair with this article
Download resources directly or send a copy to your inbox. Marketing updates are optional.
Frequency Recording Sheet
Tally countable behaviors by time block with a notes column for context
First 30 Days Behavior Data Checklist
Definitions, one home for every log, and a daily logging window
Will Your Data Habit Survive October?
See whether your behavior data routine is small enough to last through the hardest stretch of the first year.
Tags:
For classroom teams
Keep One Simple Behavior Log Going
Log frequency counts as they happen and review them on a graph with phase lines for baseline and intervention.
Create Your Free AccountFree for up to 3 students. No credit card required.
About the Author

Bobby Hillman is a Board Certified Behavior Analyst and Licensed Behavior Analyst with an M.Ed. in Special Education and more than 25 years in public special education and autism services. He works as a Behavior Instructional Specialist and founded Classroom Pulse to reduce the documentation load on classroom teams while keeping the detail FBA and BIP work requires.
About Classroom PulseRelated Articles
Bringing Behavior Data to Parent-Teacher Conferences: A 15-Minute Plan
A minute-by-minute plan for sharing behavior data in a short conference slot: one graph, a few patterns, strengths first, home observations, privacy checks, and one shared next step.
Set Up Your Behavior Data System Before Students Arrive
A one-planning-day workflow for standing up your classroom behavior data system: decide what to track, where forms and devices live, who logs what, and how baselines start in week 1.
Prompting Hierarchies: Fading Support Without Dependence
Choose prompt levels, track independence, and fade adult support without losing skill performance or creating prompt dependence.
