ESSA evidence tiers
What the evidence badge on AI intervention suggestions means, how it is assigned, and how to carry it into a BIP.
- Plans
- Practice and higher
- For:
- BCBAs and specialists, Administrators
- Read time
- 4 min read
- Updated
Where the badge appears
Every AI intervention suggestion carries a small evidence badge next to its priority. The badge reads Strong, Moderate, Promising or Rationale-based, and a What is ESSA? link beside it opens this article. Suggestions are a Practice feature; School and District plans include it.
- Open a student profile and choose the Interventions tab in the AI section. The same panel is on the Interventions page.
- Choose Generate AI Suggestions. Each suggestion shows a title, a description, its priority and the evidence badge.
- Hover over the badge to read the full tier name and the evidence threshold it represents. The badge is not a button, so there is no keyboard focus state; screen readers read the full tier name from the badge itself. On a touch screen, rely on the name printed on the badge.
The badge does not appear anywhere else. BIP drafts, intervention records, reports and exports do not carry an evidence tier.
The four tiers
The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) defines four levels of evidence for an intervention. The badge uses the same four levels.
Swipe sideways on the table to see all columns.
| Badge | ESSA level | Evidence threshold | General guidance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strong | Tier 1, strong evidence | At least one well-designed and well-implemented experimental (RCT) study showing a statistically significant effect. | Can serve as a primary intervention in a BIP. Districts may cite Tier 1 when documenting evidence for Title I, II or IV spending. |
| Moderate | Tier 2, moderate evidence | At least one well-designed and well-implemented quasi-experimental study showing a statistically significant effect. | Accepted for most Title I, II and IV uses. Some states accept Tier 2 alone; check your state ESSA plan. |
| Promising | Tier 3, promising evidence | At least one well-designed correlational study with statistical controls for selection bias. | Usually paired with progress monitoring and a fidelity plan. Record why the intervention was chosen in the BIP. |
| Rationale-based | Tier 4, demonstrates a rationale | Supported by a research-backed logic model with an effort to study effectiveness. Falls below the tiered-evidence thresholds. | Often limited to school-improvement uses unless paired with a plan to study the outcome. Record the logic model in the BIP. |
The guidance column is general. Your state plan and your district policy decide what is acceptable for a given funding source.
What Rationale-based means here
The AI model is asked to name a tier for each suggestion. When it leaves the tier out, or returns a value the app does not recognize, the app records Tier 4. Older suggestions saved before the tier existed also show Tier 4.
The app does not check the citations behind any tier, including Tier 1 to Tier 3. The badge is the model's classification, and no person has checked it until you do.
Carry the tier into a BIP
The suggestions panel has no sort or filter by tier, the tier is not saved with an intervention record, and it is not included in any export. Suggestions live in an AI cache, not in the student record. If the tier matters for your documentation, copy it yourself.
- Note the badge for the suggestion you intend to use.
- In the BIP, add the intervention name, the tier, and your own citation to the evidence section.
- For a Promising or Rationale-based intervention, add a progress-monitoring plan and a fidelity checklist alongside it.
- Have the plan reviewed by a qualified professional before implementation. The suggestion is a draft, not a recommendation from Classroom Pulse.
Legal context
The four levels come from the definition of "evidence-based" at 20 U.S.C. § 7801(21)(A). Districts that spend Title I, Title II or Title IV funds on an intervention may be asked to document which level it meets, and some state plans ask for that at the point of selection. The badge is one input to that documentation, not the documentation itself.
When something goes wrong
- Every suggestion shows Rationale-based.
- Generate the suggestions again. If the model still returns no tier, the suggestions are still usable as drafts; look up the evidence for each one yourself before using it.
- The tooltip does not open.
- The tooltip opens on hover only. On an iPad or other touch screen, use the name printed on the badge and the table above.
- I see Practice Feature instead of suggestions.
- AI intervention suggestions need the Practice plan or higher. BCBA Solo does not include them.
- The tier is missing from my export.
- That is expected. No export includes the evidence tier. Record it in the BIP evidence section by hand.
Who can use it
- Practice, School and District: AI intervention suggestions with the evidence badge.
- Free, Starter, Essential and BCBA Solo: the panel shows an upgrade prompt instead.
- Roles: anyone who can open the student profile or the Interventions page.